Welcome to Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe
Located in Saint Augustine, FL, Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe offers a cozy and intimate dining experience. With a focus on Italian cuisine, the restaurant prides itself on serving delicious dishes like chicken francese, eggplant parm, and pasta with meatballs. The attentive and friendly staff, along with ample parking and a quaint atmosphere, make it a must-visit spot for authentic Italian fare. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes, savory flavors, and homemade touches that make each meal a memorable experience. Whether you're craving seafood, soup, or classic Italian dishes, Casa Benedetto's has something for everyone to enjoy. A true gem in the culinary scene of St. Augustine.
-
197 Blackford Way Unit F Saint Augustine, FL 32086 Hotline: (904) 471-5999
Welcome to Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe, a hidden gem located in Saint Augustine, FL, offering a delightful blend of Italian cuisine and seafood.
This charming restaurant not only provides a cozy and intimate atmosphere but also offers a wide range of amenities such as takeout, reservations, delivery, and outdoor seating. With many vegetarian options available, Casa Benedetto's ensures that all guests can enjoy a delicious meal tailored to their preferences.
Highlighted by customers as a must-try spot, Casa Benedetto's signature dishes like the chicken Francese, eggplant parmigiana, and flounder have received rave reviews for their exquisite flavors and generous portions. The homemade tomato sauce and vodka sauce are also recommended for those seeking a taste of authentic Italian flavors.
The attentive service provided by the friendly staff adds to the overall dining experience, making every visit memorable and enjoyable. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch, a dinner date, or a dessert indulgence, Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe is sure to exceed your expectations.
Don't miss out on the opportunity to savor the best in Italian cuisine at Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe. Experience the warmth of traditional Italian hospitality and indulge in a culinary journey like no other. Make your reservations today and treat yourself to a taste of Italy right here in Saint Augustine, FL.
Had dinner there with another couple we all enjoyed everything from the appetizers to our espressos. Only complaint my wife said the fish was a little bland. I had chicken franceses which was incredibly delicious. Rice balls and calamari appetizers were also delicious!
An early dinner on Tuesday. First time eating at this location. We ate at their previous restaurant. Seated right away. Only one other couple here now. Yep plenty of parking out front they are an end unit to the north of Winn Dixie. My wife had the fusilli pasta with meatballs after a garden salad with house dressing. I had soup and Chicken Francese (lemon butter parsley sauce) which was very good. Joe Joe took excellent care of us. They bring out a bread basket nice and hot. Nice way to start the meal. So for us a 4. Just didn't care for the taste of their homemade tomato sauce it was good but like it a bit sweeter. Some previous reviews recommend getting their vodka sauce. Definitely worth a try.
Stopped here for lunch and it was really good. I had the eggplant parm which I thought was as good as it gets - eggplant without a huge cap of mozzarella, just enough. I think it had some ricotta as well, which made it creamier - almost lasagna-like. It came with pasta and the red sauce was rustic with some chunks of tomato. My wife had the flounder which she really liked - they made it without breadcrumbs for her. Service was friendly and prompt, there are tables for about 50-60 people; when we were there were maybe four other diners, so I can't comment about noise. I'm giving it five stars because what we had was a home-run and the overall experience was quite nice - it's reminiscent of small family-run restaurants serving quality food, which are unfortunately disapearing as chains dominate many local dining options. We will definitely be going back.
The restaurant is a bit out of the way from downtown Jacksonville but I think it's worth a drive/ They have ample parking and the restaurant itself is quaint and quirky.i was told the restaurant has been around the St Augustine area for 2decades but in different locations before moving to the current place 4 years ago. Our waiter was knowledgeable and made good recommendations. The food tasted great and had a homemade feel. The pasta was al dente. The portions were huge so if you are not a big eater, you can share with a friend. The tiramisu tasted different from what I've had in the past. I could taste the mascarpone cheese as the dominant ingredient over the chocolate / coffee. The food tasted like authentic Italian fare. Worth a trip to try it yourself!
Would give 6 stars if I could. The dinner meals were excellently prepared and savory, coming from family recipes. The prices are on the higher end, but the dinner plate sizes are rather large and could easily be split between two people. Recommend every dish we ate- artichoke sensation salad, pasta garlic and oil with broccoli, michelina's eggplant (fried well without the breading), chicken parm, shrimp scampi (well balanced butter lemon flavor), mozz caprice, crepes florentine (sauce had very flavorful buttery cream sauce and rich cheese blend inside), zuppa de' pesce (lovely presentation), fried calamari (crisply fried, tender, tentacles and rings). Staff is conversational, friendly and great with kids.
Food was superb and this was our 4th time eating here and again we were not disappointed, service was excellent and our server was great, the atmosphere is always cozy and a great way to spend the eveningwith a loved one , enjoyed a bottle of wine , had the rice balls as an appetizer,then had sausage and peppers as my entree, finished off with canolas.
OMG!!! If you want the best in Italian cuisine and at decent price with a unique decor and probably the most awesome waitress in St. Augustine this the place!!! Service A++ food quality A++ most importantly the taste!!! A++ I could not find anything wrong with this place. Yes it on the end of Winn Dixie but this place will not disappoint!! Carrie is the main server there and will take care you and will have knowledge of all the dishes. The eggplant is to die for also the bread a sauces too. And the homemade dessert!! This a no Brainer in my book!! Do yourself a favor and check it out!!!